Writer’s Relief. Kind of sounds like welfare for starving authors, doesn’t it? It turns out to be an organization that purposes to do a lot of the legwork for you, in terms of getting your book published. They’ll track down the most likely agents and publishers; edit your book, synopsis and query letter; and send you a packet of stuff that’s all ready for submission. All you need to add is postage and a prayer. I admit, I was very drawn to the idea, in spite of the huge price tag. Being completely overwhelmed at all the different roads to publication, the idea of a professional organization removing a lot of the guesswork and streamlining the process was quite tantalizing. So I went ahead and applied. It only took a couple of days for the verdict to come back … my book is too long for them to bother with.
Operating under the philosophy that any feedback, good or bad, is better than none, I’m nevertheless confused as to what I should be doing with this particular nugget … if anything. The news that my baby is a little overweight isn’t completely surprising to me. I read at least one professional editor’s blog that claimed any new author is going to have trouble selling a book that’s more than 100,000 words long. Mine tips the scale at over 200,000. I find it highly ironic that I’m now hearing the book is too long, when the very first comment I got from my husband (my first reader, my biggest supporter and an avid Sci Fi fan) was that my first draft was way too short. In the world of books like the “Song of Fire and Ice” series by George R. R. Martin — books that can take weeks to get through (for slower readers like me) — how can a book that took my husband two nights to read be too long?? Granted, he’s a fast reader, but still …
After I gave my first draft to my husband, my sister, and several friends, I incorporated all their comments into a year-long effort that I thought made the book stronger … and, yes, longer. I didn’t THINK I was making it longer for the sake of adding heft, I thought I was making it a more interesting read. I can’t remember the exact source, but I remember one author saying that a story was like a meal. You can dine on plain bread and water, or you can dine on a full turkey dinner with all the trimmings. Both will fill you up and sustain you, but which one are you going to enjoy more? So I thought I was doing a GOOD thing by adding gravy to my stuffing, topping my sweet potatoes with marshmallows, and replacing the water with wine (or beer in my case, since I don’t like wine). Did my efforts merely take my book out of contention?
Ever since I purchased the 2013 Writer’s Market and signed up for their on-line site, I’ve been inundated with e-mails from Writer’s Digest advertising any number of webinars designed to help me be a published author. Included in these ads have been webinars claiming they can teach you to write the next young adult bestseller; aimed, no doubt, at aspiring authors dreaming of creating the next Harry Potter or Katniss Everdeen. I, of course, would be lying if I said I didn’t care to aspire to those heights, but I also don’t see myself writing a book from scratch based on someone else’s idea of a good story. My story started with a tiny sprout of an idea many years ago and I’ve allowed it to grow where it would. I’d like to think that there are lots of people out there who would love it as I do, and who would be glad that you can’t finish it in one sitting. If I start cutting it back to suit one person’s idea of appropriate length, aren’t I short-changing those who want something more?
So what does one do with such a trenchant observation? Do I immediately go back and see what I can heave over the side of my overladen ship? Or should I be taking their observation quite so much to heart?
I suspect it’s far too early in the process for me to be ditching so much of my work on the recommendation of one organization. Until I have a few more rejections under my belt, I don’t think I should be abandoning my vision just yet. I think I’ll continue to hang on to the hope that there’s a niche out there somewhere for my story cycle, even if I have to e-publish to find it. But that’s an entry for another time!